What's On

Your guide to everything in North East

Secret Diner Review: The French, Manchester

The Secret Diner has been out and about and was delighted to take in lunch at the recently re-launched north west restaurant

The French in Manchester
The French in Manchester

In the unlikely event that I ever gain an entry in Who’s Who, I’m pretty certain that my list of recreations would include long lunches and sleeping.

In my case, there’s a direct correlation between the two. My lunch heaven demands a couple of spare hours and more than a couple of glasses of good wine, after which I am invariably rewarded with the sleep of the dead.

If you’re in Newcastle, my nearest 6-star favourite lunch can be found at The Raby Hunt, where the 5-course tasting menu is a bargain £35 (£55 in the evening, or the full version is £80). As an lunch outing it requires just a half-hour train journey to Darlington and a short taxi ride, although you may need someone to wake you up in Newcastle on the way back, or you could easily find yourself in Berwick.

Alternatively, if money is no obstacle, you can take the morning flight from Newcastle airport and arrive in Paris just as Chef Alain Passard, still in his jeans and casual shirt, is opening up his restaurant Arpège. Last time we were there, Mrs Diner and I were first to arrive and last to leave. We were still ploughing through his dessert tasting as the first evening diners arrived. We had to make a dash for Charles de Gaulle to catch the last flight home, and the damage to the wallet lasted for quite a while. But I still smile to think of his witty and flawless interpretations of simple fresh vegetables.

It’s easier to get to Paris for lunch than it is to Manchester. If the Government really wants to make the North an economic powerhouse, it has to start with the institution ironically called the Trans-Pennine Express. ‘Express’ is presumably used in the way the French apply it to their catering: it indicates cheap and nasty. It is also painfully slow and notoriously unreliable. But there’s sunshine at the end of the Pennine tunnel. It’s called The French.

This restaurant sits just ten minutes from Manchester Piccadilly station. The Midland hotel is a Manchester institution, where Mr Rolls first met Mr Royce. The French, its signature restaurant, won a star in the first British Michelin guide in 1974. The Beatles were famously refused entry for being “inappropriately dressed”.

Smoked Maran hens yolk with turnip, truffle and mushroom broth
Smoked Maran hens yolk with turnip, truffle and mushroom broth

After years of decay, and a sad, inauspicious period as a Crowne Plaza, The Midland was upgraded to its former glory, and in 2013 The French was relaunched to huge publicity and quite a bit of national acclaim, the creation of Simon Rogan, the wonder chef. His L’enclume in Cartmel, Cumbria, is Britain’s best restaurant, and The French has brought Rogan’s genius to Manchester, via the passion of head chef Adam Reid. I braved the train, and went for lunch with a friend.

Now call me old-fashioned, but at first I was rather disappointed by the setting. This ornate, mirrored room, which is surprisingly small, stands just off the main hotel reception. Its former rich grandeur has been softened by light Scandinavian furniture, pastel walls and huge camp chandeliers. It reminded me of those restaurants in American casinos, partitioned off from the slot machines, but with the buzz of guests always nearby. It feels more pop-up than established restaurant. The Beatles could have sneaked in with bell-bottomed jeans and Ban The Bomb t-shirts and no one would have batted an eyelid. Even the floor could be Norwegian Wood – except it’s not, it’s deep carpet woven to look like Scandinavian timber.

The result is a cool, simple, relaxed space. As simple and relaxed as the menu. 3, 6 or 10 courses, Sir? That was the choice.

We went for six (£55). At first we didn’t even glance at the list of dishes – surprise is the whole point of a tasting menu, after all – then I remembered that my friend doesn’t eat pork or shellfish. Oh dear, this was a catastrophe: our menu had trotters, ham fat, oysters, abalone, shrimp, bacon, suckling pig – there was something forbidden in almost every course. With trepidation we beckoned the waitress.

She didn’t blink. No question of ‘I’ll talk to the chef’. This was absolutely not a problem at all, Sir. And the meal arrived quickly and perfectly paired: pork replaced with chicken, bacon with beetroot, shellfish with the most ornate vegetable creations.

The cooking was modern, surprising, layered, balanced, with inspired pairings, and stunning technique. How this place didn’t achieve a Michelin star last year is beyond me. I’ve heard on the grapevine that the editor of the Michelin guide has a downer on new restaurants that only offer tasting menus. She needs to think again. This is by far the best restaurant in Manchester.

I don’t need to recite each dish: they’ve probably changed the menu completely by the time you visit, for this meal was entirely seasonal, mostly local, and utterly delicious.

From the crispy mackerel croquette with celery to the salt-baked abalone, just strong enough to complement, not destroy the butter-poached hake, to the elegantly presented pork with crab apple and a cider jus, with parsnip, broccoli, and the thinnest of allium. My favourite dish was a silky, smoked Maran hen’s egg, sitting atop yellow turnip, sprinkled with fresh Wiltshire truffles. Around it was poured an intense wild mushroom broth. Smoke, egg, turnip, truffle and mushroom? A perfect British winter combination.

We closed with baked quince and brown butter ice cream, warm and cold with crispy surprises of ginger and bay. We made up our own wine pairing from a terrific selection of wines by the glass, including Sipp Mack’s 2009 Alsace Grand Cru Rosacker Riesling. The meal took two hours: the nap lasted the entire train journey home.

You know how some food bloggers go on about the service: as if it’s a shock to discover that some restaurants unfold your napkin when you sit down? Well, allow me a little naïve gushing here. The service here was as good as it gets. Young, enthusiastic, proud staff, all of them trained in Cartmel, of course, which must be the finest catering finishing school on the planet.

In the middle of one course, I felt my napkin sliding to the floor. Before it reached the Norwegian wood, and I was just leaning down to catch it, a hand reached over and, with a quiet “Allow me, Sir”, presented me with fresh linen. The service is attentive but unobtrusive, uncloying. These waiters have eyes in the back of their head. The restaurant was almost full. I was amazed.

Manchester may seem an awful long way to go for lunch, particularly if you brave the train, but apart from the real Parisian deal, which may be quicker, but will probably break the bank, I seriously recommend The French.

Secret Diner’s verdict

(out of 5 stars)

Food 6

Service 5

Ambience 4

The French
The Midland
Peter St
M2 3NQ

0161 236 3333



David Whetstone
Culture Editor
Graeme Whitfield
Business Editor
Mark Douglas
Newcastle United Editor
Stuart Rayner
Sports Writer