Little concrete news from Defra on CAP Reform

Farmers are still waiting for Defra to fill in the detail on CAP Reform, says Claire Bainbridge of George F White in Alnwick

Claire Bainbridge
Claire Bainbridge

Over the past month there has been very little concrete news released from Defra regarding the new scheme.

The announcement at the end of April that the payment rate for Moorland would be increased by £26 per hectare (making the moorland payment up to about £56 per hectare), was very welcome for those with moorland. The 2013 payment rate was at £38, so the increase is significant.

When looked at in context with the possible payment rate of €244 for both SDA and Lowland for 2015 under the Basic Payment Scheme (approx £202), farmers with land across the North East can now start to plan what their payments could be from 2015 onwards.

Yet we still await the detail on fundamental elements to the scheme such as the definition of an active farmer, rules associated with claiming on common land, dual use and cross border farms.

More significantly, for those farming and getting on with the job, there is a significant amount of detail still to emerge on the greening elements.

There have been several reports recently in the farming press giving detail on the Ecological Focus Areas and what options are available; however, it should be made clear that Defra has still not announced what the possible options are for EFAs.

Understanding aspects of Greening such as the weighting that is being given to many of the EFA options will be important, but the reality is that until Defra release what the EFA options will be, it is hard for farmers and land managers to plan what to use or do.

One announcement that has emerged from the European Commission is that if Nitrogen Fixing crops are to be used as a possible EFA option, they will have a weighting element applied to them of 0.7.

What this means is that if you choose to plant clover as your nitrogen fixing crop to satisfy your 5% EFA requirement, you will need to plant 7.14% of your arable area (with a previous weighting of 0.3 you would have needed to plant 16.67% of your arable area).

What is also still not clear is the interaction of EFA options with stewardship scheme options. It may be that you can use an option for both your EFA and your stewardship – however if this is the case the stewardship payment could be reduced. It’s still not known whether Defra will allow double counting and how they would then apply the reduction in payment.

What is important, during this time of limbo is to start to really understand what you have on your farm. What area is classed as arable? What is permanent grassland on your holding? Do you have permanent crops?

Until you know how many hectares you have of each – which could change from year to year – it is difficult to know whether the EFA applies to your farm, how much land is required for it and whether you need to have two or three crops..

There has been guidance released by Defra in the past months. It would be hopeful to think that the full detail is finally emerging, however this is not the case. It did add definition to the Crop Diversification rules, possible exemptions and how to apply.

The three-crop rule has caused much consternation for those that it will affect. For those already growing more than three crops, the three-crop rule is of limited concern; however, for those with block cropping, two-crop rotations and contracts which restrict change, the three-crop rule may require significant adjustments to rotations, agreements, cash flow and probably the bottom line.

Exemptions for the EFAs and Crop Diversification may be applicable, but it is crucial to understand what is classed as arable and what is not.

The exemptions are precise and the hectarage of permanent grassland, fallow, temporary grassland and cropped land will all come into play in assessing whether an exemption can be applied for or not.

Without wishing to generalise most arable and mixed farms with more than 30ha of cereal cropping will not be exempt.

If you think you may be able to apply for an exemption it is wise to take advice before applying.


David Whetstone
Culture Editor
Graeme Whitfield
Business Editor
Mark Douglas
Newcastle United Editor
Stuart Rayner
Sports Writer