City regulator defends decision on former Co-operative Bank chairman Paul Flowers

A senior City regulator being grilled by a committee of MPs yesterday defended his decision to approve the appointment of disgraced former Co-operative Bank chairman Paul Flowers

Clive Adamson
Clive Adamson

A senior City regulator being grilled by a committee of MPs yesterday defended his decision to approve the appointment of disgraced former Co-operative Bank chairman Paul Flowers.

Clive Adamson, director of supervision at the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), insisted he had not made a mistake - despite Mr Flowers later being engulfed in a drugs scandal and being exposed for his lack of banking knowledge. Mr Adamson said the Methodist minister seemed to be the right person, repeatedly insisting the decision to approve him was right based on the information at the time.

He said that Mr Flowers was “not the same individual” as he seemed at a later meeting before the Treasury Select Committee last year when he appeared unable to answer basic financial questions about the bank.

Mr Adamson was quizzed by MPs on the same committee about a 90-minute meeting he and two colleagues at the now-defunct Financial Services Authority held with Mr Flowers ahead of his appointment in 2010.

At the meeting, it was agreed two deputies would be needed to assist Mr Flowers as chairman because of his lack of banking knowledge. He told the Treasury Select Committee: “I am as surprised as all of us as to the events that surrounded Mr Flowers’ apparent misdemeanours. I don’t think it was a mistake in terms of the decision that I made at the time, with the information I had.”

The Co-op Bank last year had to be rescued after a £1.5 billion hole was discovered in its finances.

Regulators on Monday announced the launch of investigations that could see former senior managers fined or banned from working in the industry.

Committee chairman Andrew Tyrie questioned whether Mr Flowers had been asked “straightforward questions” - of the kind asked by the committee that exposed his lack of banking knowledge.

Mr Adamson said: “My view at the time was that Mr Flowers did have the competence to perform the role of non-executive chairman. The non-executive chairman doesn’t run the bank, the role of non-executive chairman is to run the board.”

But Mr Tyrie told him: “It is an extraordinary state of affairs that you are asking us to believe.”

He criticised the decision to put Mr Flowers in place to oversee the board, saying: “Your solution was to put a financial illiterate in charge of it.”

Mr Adamson said he was disappointed that no one “in public life or indeed his other associations” who may have “known more about some of his misdemeanours” ever alerted regulators.

But he admitted that he had never before approved a chairman with such little experience, telling MPs: “There was no hiding the fact that he didn’t have sufficient experience.’’

Mr Adamson said Mr Flowers’ 1981 conviction for gross indecency was disclosed but it was not considered relevant and he was not questioned about it.

Journalists

David Whetstone
Culture Editor
Graeme Whitfield
Business Editor
Mark Douglas
Newcastle United Editor
Stuart Rayner
Sports Writer